The Genius of AND…

Americans, especially Christians, are known for their either/or reasoning. Something is either “this” or “that.” And usually, that means that we’re going to break down into an argument about which is “right,” and by implication, which is “wrong.” And that’s when the real fun begins. Once you have sides claiming that their solution is the only right one, you can go to war against other views.

This has been the case in the church for about a decade. There is a war that has been raging between how you do church, philosophically. The war is between Attractional church and Missional church. Put in action language, it’s a war between “Come and see” and “Go and be/tell” approaches to ministry.

Now, no one would argue that the church is not to be missional. As I preached on October 24, we are to be a sent people, ambassadors for Christ witnessing about the person and work of Christ and about His Kingdom. But very few churches put their emphasis there. Rather, the trend of the last 30 years of church history has been upon building facilities and programs designed to attract people to our Sunday morning gatherings. See the tension?

Look at the connection process. One model says “Come here to our space, believe what we believe, act like we act, and then you can be part of us.” The other says “You are so important to me and to God that I will go out and find you, entering into your world and inviting you to be in relationship with me/us in the hope that you will come to understand why we believe what we believe.”

And how you allocate resources in each of these models is very different. The key resource in the Attractional church is money since it is necessary to build better buildings and programs. The key resource in the Missional church is people, and effort is placed on helping them to understand their calling to the mission field and then on encouraging and empowering them to act.

But this week, I’m headed to the AND Conference in Indiana. The AND Conference is a conversation about how BOTH of these methods have tremendous value for the church and God’s Kingdom. It’s a conversation about how you live and minister in the tension between two very different philosophies of ministry. And I’m not even sure that there is a totally right or totally wrong answer, but I’m hopeful that the conversation will lead to deeper thought, prayerful reflection, and lively discussion about what God wants from His people at Grace Church. This is a great experience for folks who find themselves in “white space.” And inspired by the message of yesterday, I look forward to being open to the skillful hands of the Potter as He shapes me, my brothers, and our church… Yes, even in Indiana! ;o)